Women's center files motion to dismiss lawsuit filed by North Alabama man and his aborted fetus

WAAY 31 has new information on a story we've been following since February. The attorneys for the Alabama Women's Center recently filed a motion to dismiss to a lawsuit filed against them by a North Alabama man and his aborted fetus.

Ryan Magers' story is getting a ton of attention, not just in North Alabama, but nationwide. His attorney said Ryan is turning down interviews with national news media and from here out, he's not doing any more TV interviews at the request of his employer. However, we were able to sit down with his attorney, Brent Helms, on Tuesday to learn more about how they plan to move forward with this case.

Helms said it's been nearly two months since his client, Magers, filed a suit against the Alabama Women's Center for his ex-girlfriend's abortion. The attorneys for Huntsville's only abortion clinic responded by filing a motion to dismiss.

"We anticipated what they would file and were prepared for it, so now we just have to prepare for court," Helms said.

In the motion, the women's center's attorneys argue no laws were broken when Magers' ex-girlfriend aborted the fetus referred to as Baby Roe.

WAAY 31 reached out to the attorneys representing the women's center. Sara Tucker, who's based out of Atlanta, sent us this statement:

"This lawsuit is an assault on equal rights, fundamentally undermining a woman’s autonomy over her own body and the confidentiality of her own medical care. While some fringe groups hope to push healthcare for women, including abortion care, out of reach in Alabama, the law in Alabama and the United States is clear - abortion of a six week embryo is legal, constitutionally protected, and does not give rise to civil liability."

Helms responded to the motion to dismiss by saying it all comes down to whether Baby Roe is a person.

"If Baby Roe is a person and personhood is granted, which in this case it has been, then Baby Roe posses a 14th Amendment right to equal protection under the law," Helms said.

Helms is referring to a Madison County probate judge's decision to allow an estate to be opened for Baby Roe, recognizing the fetus as someone with legal rights. Helms also said there's precedent in Alabama that recognizes an unborn fetus as a person.

He's arguing that if an unborn fetus is considered a person when a pregnant woman's fetus is killed in a car wreck or a pregnant woman is murdered and the fetus is also killed, that fetus should also be viewed as a person in the case of an abortion.

"It's either an unborn child is a person or an unborn child is not a person. What we have is in congruent in the state of Alabama. We say we recognize the personhood of unborn children in certain circumstances, but not all circumstances," Helms said.

The hearing on the motion to dismiss this case is scheduled for July 24th at the Madison County Courthouse. Helms told WAAY 31 that whatever the outcome is, an appeal will likely be filed either way.

Huntsville/Redstone
Clear
48° wxIcon
Hi: 68° Lo: 40°
Feels Like: 45°
Muscle Shoals
Partly Cloudy
50° wxIcon
Hi: 72° Lo: 33°
Feels Like: 50°
Huntsville/Madison
Partly Cloudy
44° wxIcon
Hi: 68° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 41°
Decatur
Partly Cloudy
39° wxIcon
Hi: 69° Lo: 35°
Feels Like: 36°
Fort Payne
Clear
37° wxIcon
Hi: 69° Lo: 35°
Feels Like: 37°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 497154

Reported Deaths: 10029
CountyCasesDeaths
Jefferson714001387
Mobile36252736
Madison32573462
Tuscaloosa24289414
Montgomery22708519
Shelby22112215
Baldwin19856285
Lee15021155
Calhoun13755288
Morgan13742252
Etowah13379320
Marshall11439210
Houston10110262
Elmore9451185
Limestone9413136
St. Clair9003225
Cullman8979182
Lauderdale8610212
DeKalb8486175
Talladega7582165
Walker6571259
Jackson6542103
Autauga631391
Blount6229127
Colbert5998120
Coffee5259103
Dale4657107
Russell406433
Franklin399778
Covington3989106
Chilton3891100
Escambia378772
Tallapoosa3613143
Clarke343953
Chambers3423111
Dallas3419142
Pike293372
Marion288895
Lawrence284683
Winston258668
Bibb245960
Geneva240270
Marengo238357
Pickens225055
Barbour212951
Hale211969
Fayette201357
Butler201166
Henry182941
Cherokee177739
Monroe166639
Randolph164640
Washington156635
Macon147243
Crenshaw146254
Clay145554
Cleburne139741
Lamar133733
Lowndes132551
Wilcox122525
Bullock117236
Conecuh107024
Perry105927
Sumter99432
Coosa89624
Greene88532
Choctaw55123
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 777935

Reported Deaths: 11459
CountyCasesDeaths
Shelby874431502
Davidson81719870
Knox46146582
Hamilton40486462
Rutherford38479384
Williamson25338203
Sumner21415315
Montgomery17440213
Out of TN1700794
Wilson16479210
Unassigned15705126
Sullivan14396273
Blount14106182
Bradley12957140
Washington12792234
Maury12238163
Sevier12065164
Putnam10611169
Madison10109229
Robertson8980121
Hamblen8048164
Anderson8027158
Greene7301145
Tipton6953103
Coffee6357115
Dickson6239106
Gibson6196141
Cumberland6116121
Carter5983153
McMinn593992
Roane591796
Bedford5802120
Loudon570866
Jefferson5677119
Lawrence557183
Monroe534690
Warren532175
Hawkins525294
Dyer5241101
Franklin474485
Fayette467271
Obion436795
Rhea415273
Lincoln414462
Cocke400193
Cheatham393044
Marshall391256
Campbell381059
Weakley379059
Giles374496
Henderson361973
Carroll348981
White338766
Hardeman338464
Macon337073
Hardin331363
Lauderdale309242
Henry300975
Marion294544
Scott287744
Wayne287330
Overton285157
Claiborne281468
McNairy268253
DeKalb265949
Hickman265641
Haywood264860
Smith256836
Grainger243846
Trousdale239222
Morgan230138
Fentress229444
Johnson216638
Chester201948
Bledsoe200410
Crockett197347
Unicoi181147
Polk177022
Cannon176130
Union172533
Grundy169230
Lake167826
Sequatchie156427
Humphreys154221
Decatur153937
Benton151039
Lewis147225
Meigs126721
Jackson125334
Stewart123724
Clay107130
Perry103427
Houston103232
Moore94516
Van Buren79620
Pickett74623
Hancock49612

Community Events