WAAY 31 I-TEAM: Madison Co. family uneasy after loved one tests positive & negative for coronavirus

The patient was tested 4 times for the virus. 2 of those tests were performed on the same day and had different results.

Posted: Aug 11, 2020 10:11 PM
Updated: Aug 13, 2020 4:14 PM

The WAAY 31 I-TEAM worked to learn more about different coronavirus tests and their accuracy.

A family reached out to us and told us a loved one tested positive on two separate occasions before surgery at Crestwood Hospital, but tested negative for coronavirus at two different doctor's offices.

Pam Hudson, Crestwood Hospital CEO, said the hospital gives two types of test.

She said which one a patient gets is determined on a case by case basis, and that she can't comment directly on any specific cases.

The Madison County family said they just want to know if their loved one actually ever had the virus and want others to know they got multiple tests because the results didn't seem right.

"It's definitely frustrating because you've got a loved one that needs a procedure that's what I consider life-threatening. At the same time, you're being told you've got COVID, go home, you can't get the procedure until you test negative," said Scott Hudson who lives in Madison County.

Hudson said he took his loved one to Crestwood Hospital in July for surgery only to be turned away.

"It caused a lot of frustration and worry that I think was unnecessary," he said.

After a 14-day quarantine and a negative test at the family's doctor, Hudson said they rescheduled the surgery.

"Got prepped for surgery, another COVID test, tested positive again. At that point I wasn't believing it, and as we left the hospital, I went to another testing facility. We tested. A day later it came back and it was negative," he said.

Dr. Hudson, the hospital CEO, admitted some tests are more accurate than others.

"None of the tests are perfect," she said.

She explained the differences between the two different types of tests the hospital conducts.

"The antigen test is not as sensitive as we would like. It ranges depending on the different kinds of test in that category might range from 15% to 20% false negatives," she said. "A PCR test, if it's positive you can believe it. It can do a better job on the sensitivity factor so, if you have a negative PCR you're pretty sure, but it's not 100%."

Hudson said he believe his loved one was given an antigen test at the hospital because results came back in less than a half hour. He said both doctor offices the family member visited adminstered the PCR test. 

Scott Hudson remains frustrated with how everything played out. He thinks the hospital needs to test patients earlier on in the surgery process, and families should seek a second opinion if they're unsure about results.

"For surgeries they want to do a test. I would say do not hook people up to IVs and get them prepped for surgery before you test them COVID. Send them home before they have to go through all of that," he said.

He explained his loved one did end up getting the surgery after the 4 tests. The family member was always asymptomatic.

The hospital said with changing CDC guidelines a follow up test might not always be required, but they suggest anyone with concerns about testing to consult their doctor.

Huntsville
Overcast
67° wxIcon
Hi: 72° Lo: 61°
Feels Like: 67°
Florence
Overcast
69° wxIcon
Hi: 74° Lo: 63°
Feels Like: 69°
Fayetteville
Overcast
70° wxIcon
Hi: 73° Lo: 60°
Feels Like: 70°
Decatur
Overcast
67° wxIcon
Hi: 72° Lo: 61°
Feels Like: 67°
Scottsboro
Overcast
68° wxIcon
Hi: 73° Lo: 61°
Feels Like: 68°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 134231

Reported Deaths: 2357
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Jefferson19441349
Mobile13271291
Montgomery8778179
Madison775480
Tuscaloosa7496119
Shelby584951
Lee582961
Baldwin516550
Marshall390944
Calhoun346641
Etowah342047
Morgan325428
Houston278123
Elmore263247
DeKalb239120
Walker228483
St. Clair227837
Talladega212728
Limestone206120
Cullman188519
Dallas177426
Franklin175529
Russell17442
Autauga173825
Lauderdale168233
Colbert163626
Blount159415
Escambia158425
Jackson154611
Chilton153531
Dale135444
Covington134427
Coffee13078
Pike11879
Chambers115142
Tallapoosa114685
Clarke107717
Marion95729
Butler91339
Barbour8577
Winston73712
Marengo70820
Lowndes65327
Pickens65114
Bibb64210
Randolph63713
Hale62828
Lawrence60922
Geneva5995
Bullock59814
Cherokee59115
Monroe5818
Clay5707
Washington55613
Perry5407
Conecuh53111
Crenshaw53132
Wilcox53111
Henry4865
Macon48020
Fayette4438
Sumter43419
Lamar3632
Choctaw34612
Cleburne3396
Greene30315
Coosa1673
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Confirmed Cases: 187690

Reported Deaths: 2312
CountyConfirmedDeaths
Shelby30460452
Davidson26252298
Hamilton928791
Knox918175
Rutherford915088
Williamson516536
Sumner475896
Wilson341844
Putnam320139
Montgomery302244
Out of TN296825
Unassigned29145
Bradley289317
Madison280061
Sevier257015
Blount247723
Maury230923
Washington223935
Robertson219035
Sullivan212133
Hamblen188525
Tipton178118
Trousdale16517
Gibson160922
Hardeman154826
Wayne14905
Bedford132017
Dyer131813
Dickson123515
Cumberland117518
Fayette117418
Coffee116613
Weakley115719
Anderson115312
Henderson115322
Carter114728
Obion11389
Loudon11356
Greene112943
McMinn110025
Jefferson109714
Macon103520
Warren10267
Monroe102217
Lawrence101211
Hardin100516
Lauderdale95915
Haywood95418
Franklin9518
Lake9142
Roane8724
Carroll85819
Bledsoe8494
McNairy84218
White8139
Cheatham80610
Rhea79812
Hawkins78316
Cocke7419
Marshall7415
Overton7135
Smith69810
Johnson6752
Henry6139
Chester60910
Lincoln6031
Giles58017
Hickman5585
DeKalb55213
Crockett52919
Marion5187
Decatur5037
Fentress4713
Claiborne4405
Campbell4314
Polk38210
Grainger3633
Union3471
Benton3349
Jackson3175
Morgan3113
Unicoi2831
Cannon2800
Grundy2685
Humphreys2443
Sequatchie2293
Meigs2233
Clay2205
Houston2083
Scott2072
Stewart1902
Lewis1851
Moore1641
Van Buren1600
Perry1490
Pickett1102
Hancock1063

Community Events