WAAY 31 I-TEAM: Former warden talks about accused triple-killer Jimmy Spencer

Jimmy Spencer's warden sizes up the ex-con and has sharp criticism of the parole board that set the now accused killer free.

Posted: Sep 25, 2019 5:28 PM
Updated: Sep 25, 2019 5:30 PM

Jimmy Spencer is the ex-con accused of last year's cold-blooded triple-killing in Guntersville. The brutal murders happened not long after Alabama’s parole board OK'ed Spencer’s release from prison.

WAAY 31's Greg Privett talked with one of Spencer’s former wardens about warning signs that could have kept the accused killer locked up.

“I wouldn’t have let him out,” David Wise told WAAY 31. Wise was the warden at St. Clair Correctional Facility. “Oh, I knew him at St. Clair. And he was trouble. I don’t know how he got out.”

Wise has choice words about Jimmy Spencer. “He was just, for lack of a better term, scum,” Wise said.

Spencer’s charged in the killings of a Guntersville grandmother, her grandson visiting from Huntsville and the woman’s neighbor.

“I sized him up," Wise told us. "He was a troublemaker. He got some disciplinary reports. He didn’t get along well with the staff. He had a terrible record.”

The murders happened in July of last year. The Alabama Board of Pardons and Paroles released Spencer six months earlier.

“I would say the judgment wasn’t good on that one,” Wise said. “I knew that inmate. And he never should have been let out. Spencer is one of those that should have never been let out.”

There was a long list of warning signs that could have kept Spencer locked up. He had trouble coping inside prison walls. Inside St. Clair, Spencer had violent outbursts, broke rules and constantly challenged corrections officers.

“If you can’t get along inside there, what makes you think you can get along outside here," Wise said. "And to me, no convict should get out on parole. I don’t care what he’s convicted of if he can’t show respect for the staff and the rules and regulation of the facility.”

Even so, Wise says deciding whether to release an inmate on parole means weighing risk.

“I think it’s a very difficult job to do," he said. "It’s a risk. And any way you look at it, corrections and parole are in the risk business. It’s just the way it is. You take a risk any time you let one out.”

He said even a non-violent inmate could do the unthinkable. “He could get out and kill somebody the next day.”

Wise insists there were missed opportunities to lock Spencer back inside prison walls.

“What really bothers me about the Spencer case is they were notified when he left that halfway house or whatever it was down in Birmingham. And no action was taken. They didn’t find him. They should have found him and locked him back up then.”

David Wise says Alabama's parole board should listen closely to corrections officers because they know the inmates.

“You have to really get inside the guy’s head," he said. "Why don’t you call that corrections officer that’s been walking around with this guy for 10 years and ask him some questions? “What about that correctional officer down in that cell block? He talked to him every day. He’s the one that watched his habits every day. He’s the one or she’s the one that knows this guy personally. Why not talk to them?”

Huntsville/Redstone
Partly Cloudy
43° wxIcon
Hi: 62° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 43°
Muscle Shoals
Partly Cloudy
49° wxIcon
Hi: 64° Lo: 32°
Feels Like: 49°
Huntsville/Madison
Partly Cloudy
42° wxIcon
Hi: 62° Lo: 31°
Feels Like: 42°
Decatur
Partly Cloudy
43° wxIcon
Hi: 64° Lo: 34°
Feels Like: 43°
Fort Payne
Partly Cloudy
39° wxIcon
Hi: 62° Lo: 32°
Feels Like: 39°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 524367

Reported Deaths: 10807
CountyCasesDeaths
Jefferson756511496
Mobile40258800
Madison34165498
Tuscaloosa25448445
Montgomery24089574
Shelby23250243
Baldwin20787302
Lee15670166
Calhoun14375313
Morgan14180274
Etowah13716348
Marshall12022220
Houston10427279
Elmore10011202
Limestone9873149
Cullman9512191
St. Clair9508236
Lauderdale9293234
DeKalb8774183
Talladega8131173
Walker7153277
Autauga6793107
Jackson6772110
Blount6556133
Colbert6240132
Coffee5435113
Dale4780111
Russell432139
Franklin421882
Chilton4153110
Covington4084116
Tallapoosa3943149
Escambia390375
Dallas3529150
Chambers3526122
Clarke347660
Marion3084100
Pike306776
Lawrence297696
Winston273272
Bibb256961
Marengo248461
Geneva246475
Pickens233359
Barbour228455
Hale219175
Butler214068
Fayette210560
Henry188344
Cherokee182945
Randolph178741
Monroe174040
Washington165838
Macon156849
Clay150956
Crenshaw149957
Cleburne147141
Lamar139834
Lowndes137853
Wilcox125427
Bullock122140
Conecuh109828
Perry107626
Sumter103332
Coosa100928
Greene91534
Choctaw59024
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 837833

Reported Deaths: 12111
CountyCasesDeaths
Shelby933421591
Davidson88250926
Knox49926625
Hamilton43501488
Rutherford42422423
Williamson27589215
Sumner23549345
Montgomery19740224
Wilson18547229
Out of TN1797995
Unassigned16778133
Sullivan16266287
Blount15213194
Bradley14670148
Washington14243244
Maury13261170
Sevier13204175
Putnam11193173
Madison10853241
Robertson9627129
Anderson8639171
Hamblen8522171
Greene7746152
Tipton7235104
Coffee6833121
Dickson6740109
Cumberland6586128
Carter6487156
Bedford6439129
Gibson6410144
McMinn637897
Roane6197102
Jefferson6089124
Loudon602469
Lawrence582086
Hawkins5802106
Monroe572495
Warren551881
Dyer5371104
Franklin509488
Fayette493678
Obion450396
Cheatham445954
Cocke444298
Rhea431575
Lincoln430963
Marshall412358
Campbell410562
Weakley403763
Giles396299
Henderson373276
Macon358677
Carroll357782
White356269
Hardin350566
Hardeman346764
Lauderdale314444
Henry312675
Marion310846
Claiborne307373
Scott305745
Overton298161
Wayne294434
Hickman280746
McNairy277254
DeKalb275753
Smith275238
Haywood268461
Grainger259649
Trousdale249122
Morgan246339
Fentress238446
Johnson232238
Bledsoe210111
Chester209651
Crockett201548
Polk200324
Unicoi195249
Cannon189231
Union186534
Grundy178433
Humphreys174622
Lake169626
Sequatchie167028
Benton163440
Decatur157538
Lewis156626
Meigs135124
Stewart131028
Jackson130035
Clay109431
Houston108633
Perry105728
Moore100217
Van Buren83622
Pickett75724
Hancock55712

Community Events