WAAY 31 I-Team Investigation: Spencer Victim: 'I wish I would have killed him'

One of Jimmy Spencer's original victims from Franklin County exclusively spoke with WAAY31.

Posted: Aug 9, 2018 6:29 PM
Updated: Oct 15, 2018 2:31 PM

Thursday, the WAAY 31 I-team talked to a man who could’ve killed a triple murder suspect 30 years ago.

Our victim in this case did not want his identity revealed, because that's how dangerous Jimmy Spencer is. He told us he was in the Franklin County Courthouse in 1990 when Jimmy Spencer was sentenced to life in prison. Our victim said he breathed a sigh of relief that day, but that relief is now replaced by anger at the Alabama Parole Board and regrets.

"I'm extremely angry and there is a lot of anguish involved in this. This should have never occurred," said Spencer's original victim from Franklin County.

He tells us it was a January night in 1989 that changed his life. A friend of the man's had just come by and mentioned the police were after Jimmy Spencer and warned him to be careful, because he had been spotted in the area. Our victim said he dozed off on the couch, with a 357 magnum pistol close. He told us at his home in Vina one of the windows wouldn't lock and he's a light sleeper. That night he woke up to strange noises and went to check it out near that window that gave him trouble.

"He [Spencer] was fully inside the house except for his right leg. I thought, I don't want to kill this man. I don't want to kill this intruder but i'm not going to let him get in my home," said the man.

He showed us the gun he used to shoot Spencer with. Spencer already had numerous burglary charges, and was actually out on parole in 1989 when he broke into our victims home, which was a parole violation. People in Franklin County knew how dangerous Spencer could be and our victim said he terrorized the area.

"People in the Vina community were scared. They were actually frightened. They were afraid to leave home and if they did, they were afraid to come back," said the man.

With one shot to the shoulder, our victim took people's fears away. Spencer was caught and sentenced to life. Our victim fought to keep him there. He said he wrote letters to the parole board in 2008 and 2013 after they notified him that Spencer was up for parole, asking the parole board to keep Spencer locked up. He said he was not notified in 2017 about Spencer's parole hearing, Spencer was released in January 2018. He’s charged with killing three people in Guntersville last month.

"They let scum like this out. This is an insult to everyone," he said.

Our victim said it's hard to describe the moment he heard about the new charges against Spencer.

"I cried. Hurt, mad, bitter," he said.

Our victim said he regrets not killing Spencer in 1989.

"Some people might think that's morbid, but that's exactly how I feel about it. Vermon like this need to snuffed out like a candle," said the victim.

We have called the parole board numerous times, and filed multiple open records requests to find out how Spencer fell through the cracks of the justice system. once we get those documents we will let you know.

Huntsville
Scattered Clouds
32° wxIcon
Hi: 50° Lo: 26°
Feels Like: 27°
Florence
Clear
33° wxIcon
Hi: 52° Lo: 29°
Feels Like: 33°
Fayetteville
Clear
34° wxIcon
Hi: 49° Lo: 24°
Feels Like: 29°
Decatur
Clear
27° wxIcon
Hi: 51° Lo: 25°
Feels Like: 22°
Scottsboro
Clear
28° wxIcon
Hi: 52° Lo: 25°
Feels Like: 28°
WAAY Radar
WAAY WAAY-TV Cam
WAAY Temperatures

Alabama Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 252900

Reported Deaths: 3638
CountyCasesDeaths
Jefferson33526501
Mobile20103365
Madison13723151
Tuscaloosa13366154
Montgomery12552236
Shelby1079677
Baldwin9051137
Lee787266
Morgan696451
Calhoun6598121
Etowah656167
Marshall647357
Houston541038
DeKalb498137
Cullman462443
St. Clair441956
Limestone440445
Lauderdale426754
Elmore421164
Walker3735111
Talladega370157
Jackson340423
Colbert332042
Blount306140
Autauga281842
Franklin257434
Coffee250015
Dale239054
Dallas231532
Chilton228939
Russell22663
Covington225034
Escambia202331
Tallapoosa187291
Chambers182750
Pike161514
Clarke161019
Marion144736
Winston137523
Lawrence133436
Pickens126518
Geneva12508
Marengo123424
Bibb120418
Barbour118911
Butler118642
Randolph105522
Cherokee105124
Hale98131
Fayette94616
Washington93219
Clay92824
Henry8896
Monroe83011
Lowndes80929
Cleburne78814
Macon75522
Crenshaw72230
Bullock70119
Lamar7018
Conecuh70014
Perry6916
Wilcox64818
Sumter58622
Greene43518
Choctaw43114
Coosa3664
Out of AL00
Unassigned00

Tennessee Coronavirus Cases

Cases: 380186

Reported Deaths: 4638
CountyCasesDeaths
Shelby49077671
Davidson43915423
Knox19739155
Rutherford18613164
Hamilton17549154
Williamson1183781
Sumner10255137
Out of TN832854
Wilson788382
Montgomery700185
Sullivan6787102
Washington6360109
Maury626169
Putnam607483
Blount586362
Bradley558337
Madison5519111
Sevier521933
Unassigned513922
Robertson395453
Tipton379439
Hamblen367961
Gibson334068
Greene330473
Dyer328352
Anderson316730
Dickson302535
Coffee299042
Bedford292232
Carter290558
Lawrence284134
Obion274850
McMinn273855
Cumberland269937
Roane251929
Warren248420
Jefferson241233
Loudon239520
Fayette232939
Monroe229544
Hardeman228838
Weakley223136
Franklin221036
Lauderdale210124
Hawkins207135
Wayne196210
Henderson191834
Trousdale191812
Macon187429
White186219
Rhea184334
Marshall182722
Hardin182125
Carroll181235
Lincoln171118
Cheatham168517
Cocke168330
Haywood166530
Campbell163123
Henry160818
Overton156635
Giles153349
Smith148820
Johnson144723
McNairy143133
Fentress125320
DeKalb123522
Hickman122619
Bledsoe11945
Lake11826
Crockett117727
Marion115319
Scott11447
Grainger108217
Chester104421
Decatur96413
Claiborne9339
Unicoi91826
Benton86414
Grundy80014
Cannon7954
Lewis78714
Morgan7806
Union7535
Humphreys7508
Jackson71210
Polk70415
Stewart61915
Houston59920
Clay56218
Sequatchie5555
Meigs51613
Perry49821
Moore4082
Pickett40014
Van Buren3832
Hancock1854

Community Events