Defense rests in Huntsville Police Officer William Darby murder trial

A total of nine witnesses were called by the defense.

Posted: May 5, 2021 1:58 PM
Updated: May 5, 2021 11:14 PM

Huntsville Police Officer William Darby took the stand in his own defense at his murder trial Wednesday. 

This is the third day of his murder trial in the death of Jeffrey Parker. The prosecution rested its case Tuesday (see that HERE).

Huntsville Police Officer William Darby testifying during his murder trial

Darby is charged with shooting a suicidal Parker in 2018 while Parker held a gun to his own head.

On the stand Wednesday, Darby testified that he feared he was going to see "one of my officers" get hurt. The defense claimed Parker was an imminent threat to both Darby and the other officers on scene. 

A total of nine witnesses were called by the defense. 

Before Darby took the stand, the defense brought in several expert witnesses to discuss action reaction. Essentially, if a person has a gun, no matter where it is pointed, there's a chance that person can shoot you before you have a chance to react.

The defense also brought the head of training for the Huntsville Police Department. He said based on Darby's training, Darby did exactly what he was supposed to do, because Parker having a gun put all the officers in imminent threat.

When Darby took the stand, he claimed he had to take action. He said Officer Genisha Pegues, the first officer to arrive at the scene that day, was not thinking "correctly." 

Pegues had more than 10 years combined experience policing, according to prosecutors. At the time of the shooting, Darby had 18 months. 

The defense had Darby walk them through body camera footage showing the moment leading up to the fatal shooting. The entire event happened within seconds. Only 25 seconds after telling Pegues to point the gun at Parker, Darby pulled the trigger.

Darby explained he was trying to come up with a plan as quickly as possible. He said he and the other officers were in a fatal funnel, since Parker had a gun.

Once the prosecution started cross-examining, they questioned whether or not having a gun to your head is illegal. Darby answered it was not. 

The prosecutor then asked, "So, he had not done anything worthy of being arrested, but he had done something worthy of death?"

Darby answered, “In this case, he had done things worthy of deadly force taken on him.”

Prosecutors argue the threat was not imminent since the danger was not immediate, certain or unequivocal. 

Closing arguments from both sides will be made Thursday, followed by jury deliberation.

WAAY 31 Reporter Alex Torres-Perez was inside the courtroom Wednesday and tweeting Darby’s testimony. Click below to follow her on Twitter or add her by clicking HERE.

75° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 58°
Feels Like: 75°
77° wxIcon
Hi: 81° Lo: 56°
Feels Like: 78°
76° wxIcon
Hi: 83° Lo: 58°
Feels Like: 76°
Partly Cloudy
75° wxIcon
Hi: 82° Lo: 58°
Feels Like: 75°
WAAY Radar
WAAY Temperatures


Community Events